Resolve HMRC disputes, go with a voluntary settlement

If you are a contractor and are in the process of disputing an HMRC investigation, it may be worth considering a voluntary settlement. Emma Perry BSc ACA, tells you why you should give this some thought…

5 Minute Read

Last Updated: 14th March 2022

If you are a contractor and are in the process of disputing an HMRC investigation, it may be worth considering a voluntary settlement. Emma Perry BSc ACA, tells you why you should give this some thought below.

Of the 65,000 individuals and businesses under investigation for having used various tax reducing schemes, many may be required to pay the amount of tax in dispute before the end of this year!

When the new law receives Royal Assent in about mid-July 2014 those with an open enquiry or appeal may receive a notice to pay the tax upfront where their case is deemed by HMRC to be similar to another scheme that has been defeated in the Courts.

This will also apply to any scheme reported under the Disclosure of Tax Avoidance Scheme rules (DOTAS) or where a General Anti-Abuse Rule (GAAR) Counter-action Notice has been issued.

It is estimated that it will take three to four years for HMRC to contact and request payment from all of those expected to make upfront payments.

The new tax rules will apply to employee benefit trusts, contractor avoidance, partnership schemes and stamp duty land tax. However, contractor avoidance is likely to be the largest category where this involved individuals using offshore intermediaries to obtain loans instead of remuneration, in an attempt to avoid or defer Income Tax.

The Queen’s Speech 2014 announced similar measures to be enacted for National Insurance Contributions.

Those affected are required to take “corrective action” to resolve their dispute.
HMRC are using this new tax regime “to rebalance the economics of entering into avoidance schemes” by getting taxpayers “to pay disputed tax earlier in the process”.

Now is perhaps a final opportunity to consider and, if appropriate, start voluntary settlement negotiations with HMRC to possibly avoid National Insurance, penalties, Follower and Accelerated Payment Notices.

Emma qualified as a Chartered Accountant (ACA) in 2009 and is a Member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England & Wales. She worked with Harvard Business School and for Deloitte, Intermediate Capital Group and Fitch Ratings before establishing her own practice. Emma is a member of the Tax Faculty and Tax Investigation Practitioners Group. Should you need assistance with an HMRC dispute, you can call her on 07811 767 478 or email

Trusted by over 15,000 subscribers

You don't need to be an expert to complete your self assessment tax return.

Start your free trial

Blog content is for information purposes and over time may become outdated, although we do strive to keep it current. It's written to help you understand your Tax's and is not to be relied upon as professional accounting, tax and legal advice due to differences in everyone's circumstances. For additional help please contact our support team or HMRC.


Start your Self Assessment tax return today for free.

Sign up Now

How much tax does a landlord need to pay? 10 key questions answered…

18 May 2023

The UK has more than 2.7m unincorporated landlords and each year they report to HMRC rental property income worth some £41bn. Unincorporated landlords are…

How to claim a tax rebate when you’re a sole trader

04 May 2023

Even if it’s only a few quid, finding out that you’re in line for a tax rebate because you’ve paid too much tax is…

21 expenses you can claim as a private residential landlord

02 May 2023

Being a landlord can be costly. There are so many things to buy and expenses to pay, while repairs and maintenance work can really…

How GoSimpleTax Works


Simply register for free with your full name and email address.

Select Your Income

Select the income you receive and follow the hints and tips for potential tax savings.

Validate Your Information

Validate your personal information and submit directly to HMRC to get confirmation in just seconds.


Work Anywhere, With Any Device

Gone are the days of fretting over a calculator surrounded by scraps of paper at the eleventh hour.

GoSimpleTax’s tax return software uses the information you upload in real time to calculate your income and expenditure, working out the tax you owe and sending you helpful notifications when there’s the possibility of a mistake.

Start your free trial

"The software is intuitive and proved very easy to navigate. I found the whole process refreshingly simple. I saved a lot of money too!"

Steve J.

Ordained Presbyter

"Easy to use and value for money. Everything you need to do your tax."

Gordon J.

Self Employed

"It fills in all the forms and sends them to the Inland Revenue. Not expensive either. Takes the stress out of doing your tax return online."

Ross G.

Team Rector

Start your free trial